Beaumont logo

S10E3: Stakeholder management – making good decisions

October 13, 2026
Season 10: stakeholder management

Episode description

Stakeholders: mapped
Conversations: had
Consensus: missing

Episode three in this series on stakeholder management looks at what happens when you’ve gathered every perspective and there’s still no obvious answer (which, let’s be honest, is most of the time).

Imogen and Amanda work through how to get clear on what the real decision is, who needs to make it, and how you can make a choice without being 100% sure. 

Transcript

[00:00:05.600] - Imogen
Hello, and welcome to Dear Comms, the coffee break podcast where we tackle your biggest corporate comms challenges. I'm Imogen. 
[00:00:12.510] - Amanda
And I'm Amanda. We're here to give you practical, no-nonsense advice, so you can focus on the things that will really drive influence, engagement, and impact. Last time, we talked about finding common ground with stakeholders, understanding their different perspectives, and because of it, having better stakeholder conversations. 
[00:00:34.800] - Imogen
Yeah, but conversations are well and good, but you actually have to do something with those conversations. They have to lead somewhere. You've got to start making decisions based on those conversations. And that's what we're going to talk about today. How do you make good decisions if you are faced with a group of stakeholders who all want different things? 
[00:00:54.430] - Amanda
And that's not easy. I think one of the things is quite challenging, is accepting that different people's Several different people can be right at the same time. You know, you're dealing with a situation internally, finance can be right, but operations can be right too. Customers can be right, and regulators and the local community can be right. I guess the challenge here is not deciding who's right, it's deciding what's right for the organization that you're working in or advising. 
[00:01:26.440] - Imogen
Yeah, and it's harder. Than it sounds when you've got all of these different competing opinions, and everyone's making very reasonable points about what they believe and what they think is the right way to go, but they are all looking at things through very different perspectives, different lenses. They are bringing their own feelings, their own values, their own position into it, and it's not about picking sides. It's about bringing all of those perspectives together, aligning them, making sure we're all going in the same direction, and then helping the organization make the best decision. Where do organizations typically get stuck, do you think? 
[00:02:10.730] - Amanda
I think it's because we naturally, as communicators or as leadership teams, want to jump straight to solutions. We just wanna get in there and fix it. And I think, What I would advise is slow the conversation down. Because, you know, if you— you've got to be really clear about the decision you're actually making. Now, that sounds a little bit obvious, but it's amazing how organizations are trying to solve 3 or 4 different decisions at the same time. 
[00:02:44.920] - Imogen
What do you mean by that? 
[00:02:46.640] - Amanda
So, let's say you're making a significant change, or restructuring, closing a site. You could be changing a product, you could be launching a major development, you know, launching a new policy, maybe. One discussion is, should we do it? Another one is, when should we do it? Then we've got, how should we do it? Then the communications, so how are we gonna explain it? They're all important parts of that decision, but they are different decisions. And I think unless you separate them out, it's very difficult to move forward. 
[00:03:22.460] - Imogen
Yeah, and I think that's why sometimes we can get frustrated, because meetings are going around in circles and you've talked about everything and decided nothing. And that's because your different key components of that decision are all talking about different parts of the puzzle. 
[00:03:38.730] - Amanda
Yeah. 
[00:03:39.150] - Imogen
So I think one of the simplest things that you can do is take a step back and ask, what is the decision that we need to make today, right now? So not next month, not next year, but today. And if we start getting people sort of thinking in the immediate, then that really changes the conversation. So, once we've figured out, okay, what do we need to decide today? Then the question becomes, okay, who needs to be involved? 
[00:04:10.300] - Amanda
I think another mistake organizations make is trying to involve everybody in everything. It always sounds inclusive, but it usually isn't very effective. Not everybody needs to contribute in the same way. You know, you've got your decision shapers, That might be your executive team. You've got your experts, your technical experts, or it might be an external regulator whose input changes the decision altogether. You know, some need to approve it, some people need to deliver it, others just simply need to understand it. And I think if you try and treat them all the same, it often slows things down. And as you rightly said, things go round in circles. 
[00:04:49.740] - Imogen
Yeah. So, as managers of stakeholders, I guess, we need to know who needs which conversation and when. And that's where things like a RACI, or a RACI, as some people call it, I call it a RACI, comes in very handy. You know who's responsible, who needs to take actions, who needs to be involved, et cetera. So instead of trying to wrangle and have the same conversation with a whole load of different people who might not need all of that information, it's about understanding who needs what information for what purpose and when. And then once that's clear and you have that and everyone's signed up to that, then your process becomes a lot more simpler. 
[00:05:32.130] - Amanda
Yeah, it's a good point. And I think right at this point, we're not talking about communications, just writing messages. We're talking about helping organizations make better decisions. And sometimes that's asking the question nobody else has asked yet. Now, communicators are usually pretty good at that, Are we solving the right problem? Are we making the right decision? I think those questions can save weeks of unnecessary debate. 
[00:05:59.350] - Imogen
Yeah, and it's questions actually I find that some leaders don't like to ask because they don't want to know the answer. 
[00:06:05.030] - Amanda
You're so right. 
[00:06:05.680] - Imogen
And that's the problem. But I think once we've worked out this is the right problem, this is the right decision, and we have the right people, we can sometimes get to a point where there still isn't an obvious answer. And sometimes that's just the reality of being a leader. 
[00:06:29.440] - Amanda
And I think one thing we haven't talked about here is confusing noise with importance, 'cause I think that's a big factor here. Just because an issue is getting the most attention doesn't automatically make it the biggest challenge or the biggest risk to a decision. 
[00:06:47.450] - Imogen
Yeah, and that's true internally and externally, I think. We've all been in those situations where there's one person who speaks the most at a meeting, or there's a customer who is shouting the loudest, or there is one little niche corner of social media. And while that noise can be confusing and worrying, Doesn't necessarily mean it's that important. 
[00:07:15.600] - Amanda
I remember standing in the back garden of a local neighbor to a brownfield site. It was a smelly petrol station that we were trying to develop into a McDonald's whilst I was in McDonald's. And we agreed to meet this neighbor to discuss the issues, and we got met by 40 people in this garden. And it was very easy to get distracted by those vocal individuals about the issues. But actually, when you went out and met other people, they had other concerns that needed solving and dealing with. So that, you know, person being the loudest or making the biggest noise isn't necessarily key to the decision. And I think that's where you have to weigh up the consequences, not simply reacting to what's in front of you, but balancing each important decision, because it's gonna— it gives you something, or it costs you something. You kind of— trick is avoiding the trade-off, it's, you know, or making the right trade-off, put it that way. 
[00:08:29.730] - Imogen
Yeah, I don't think it has to be a zero-sum game though. It doesn't mean because you win, I lose. And different stakeholders are going to judge the decisions made differently. And there is no perfect answer. And as with so much in life, it's just the best answer or the best decision that you can make with the information that you've got and the resources that you've got at the time. 
[00:08:55.490] - Amanda
Yeah. And sometimes you just have to recognize you've got enough information, enough evidence, enough challenge, enough different perspectives, and you've got to make a decision. Because if you're an organization and a leader in that organization, it's not just about making good decisions, it's about making them timely, at the right time. 
[00:09:18.070] - Imogen
Yeah, it reminds me of what Nell was saying in our podcast with her about decision-making, and talking about this idea of, for the most part, people get to sort of 90% that they've made a decision, but they keep on holding out for that 100%, which might never come, and they're so worried about just making a decision with enough information that they had. But when we have that decision, then it's the turn of comms again, and not to change the decision, although sometimes I would like to be in that position, but it's about helping people understand why the decision's been made. 
[00:09:57.100] - Amanda
Yeah, can we explain why? Why this decision? Why now? not another option. I think if leaders can explain their thinking, I think even those difficult decisions become easier to hear. 
[00:10:12.130] - Imogen
So if we were to leave people with 3 things from today, I think, first off, be clear about the decision that you're making. Secondly, accept that every decision is going to have trade-offs and compromises. But thirdly, make sure that you can explain your thinking, you can explain the why. 
[00:10:33.280] - Amanda
Yeah, and that judgment isn't about making everybody happy, accept that. It's about balanced decisions and having the confidence to stand behind them. 
[00:10:44.690] - Imogen
Yeah, I will put a note in the show notes, I'll put Nell's LinkedIn and website there, because she is an absolute guru at making decisions and helping people make decisions. So she may be helpful for you. Next time we're going to move on from decision-making, we're going to start talking about relationships, because no matter what decision is made, it is going to be difficult for somebody to hear. 
[00:11:09.970] - Amanda
Yeah, and we'll, we'll talk about how you keep those relationships constructive, even when people don't agree with the outcome. 
[00:11:19.510] - Imogen
All right, well, until then. 
[00:11:22.110] - Amanda
Take care. 

Latest podcasts

S10E3: Stakeholder management – making good decisions

S10E3: Stakeholder management – making good decisions

  • Season 10: stakeholder management
Stakeholders: mappedConversations: hadConsensus: missing Episode three in this series on stakeholder management looks at what happens when you’ve gathered every perspective and there’s still no obvious answer (which, let’s be…
Listen
© Beaumont Communications 2015 - 2026
A woman with glasses and dark hair sipping a drink from a metal cup with a straw in a café.
Deborah brings a wide range of skills to her work. She works on everything from ideas, to content creation, to website governance.

She is dedicated to helping clients meet the communications challenges brought about by today’s fast-paced, multi-media world. She’s partnered with clients from many different industries tackling a variety of content assessment and strategy, social media and community management and site transition projects.

Deborah Menikoff

A smiling woman with short red hair wearing a red and green patterned shawl and a blue patterned scarf, holding a takeaway coffee cup in front of a brick wall.

Ilona Tofahrn-Flint

Ilona has over 15 years’ design experience working for both multi-national companies and agencies in London.

From designing magazines, to logo and branding, to communications materials and presentations – whatever the brief, Ilona relishes a challenge. She always offers a different view, introducing fresh ideas and novel design solutions that elevate any project she works on.

Although originally from Germany, she is proud to have lived in the UK long enough to call herself an English Rose! Ilona hates clip art and comic sans (who doesn’t? 😊)
A smiling woman with curly brown hair and blue eyes in a headshot photo.

Elissa Bertot

Elissa is on a mission to help clients build a brand they’re proud of. Drawing on 15 years’ experience in communications, branding and marketing, she mixes brand strategy with change management to transform the way organisations communicate, internally and externally.

A true word nerd, she combines strategy with creativity to develop messages and content that engage audiences across industries.

Elissa bridges the gap between public and private sectors, working with corporations, non-profits, NGOs and social impact startups alike. As an experienced speaker and trainer, she uses her expertise to empower clients and organisations to drive change and tell stories that inspire action.
A laughing woman with short brown hair wearing a floral bomber jacket and jeans, leaning against a fallen log with a stone building in the background.

Laura Hurst

Having cut her teeth in the print industry (and has the paper cuts to prove it), Laura now has over twelve years' experience as a graphic designer, with a focus on branding and publication design.

Laura combines professionalism with fun and creativity, and loves drawing inspiration from the world around her. Her favourite part of the design process is getting to know the client, deeply understanding their needs and motivations. This, she believes, is the basis of great design.

Outside of work Laura can be found pursuing quite a few different hobbies, including knitting, painting and most recently, rollerskating.
A smiling woman with short red hair holding a baby goat in her arms outdoors at a farm.

Amanda Pierce

Amanda is a senior communications and change advisor with extensive experience working alongside high-profile leaders and organisations on strategy, reputation, and decision-making. She has held senior leadership roles both in consultancy and in-house, including as UK CEO of Burson-Marsteller.

Amanda is particularly trusted for her judgement and ability to cut through complexity - she is known for one of the best “sniff tests” in the business. She takes a calm, considered approach to situations, particularly those which are sensitive, fast-moving, or ambiguous.

She has worked across a wide range of sectors including healthcare, food, natural resources, and manufacturing – often in environments shaped by regulation, public opinion, and competing stakeholder expectations. She understands that progress depends not only on strong strategy, but also on how people feel informed, involved, and confident in their role.

A scientist by training, Amanda values evidence as well as emotion when it comes to communicating. She is known as a trusted sounding board who can help leaders think clearly, act decisively, and lead with confidence.
A smiling woman with long blonde hair and feather earrings, standing in front of shelves of colourful yarn.

Imogen Hitchcock MCIPR

Imogen is a senior communications consultant who has spent her career helping individuals, teams, and organisations navigate complex change - transforming strategy into stories that inspire, engage, and motivate.

Not one to shy away from asking the tough questions, she combines curiosity with a strong focus on outcomes. Imogen believes in the power of “normal not formal” language: clear, simple communication, free from corporate jargon. She thrives when elevating the mundane, the technical, or the difficult into content that’s influential, powerful, and human.

Imogen has experience across the public and private sectors in high-profile and fast-paced environments where clarity, credibility, and agility matter. She supports and coaches leaders and practitioners to develop well-defined narratives that build confidence, aid decision making, and drive action. She cares deeply about fairness, transparency, and helping others to feel part of the process.

She loves cheese, wonderful writing, rugby, and the Archers.